nationbooksprojectofnation

posted January 24, 2009 10:56 am

Tomgram: Waltz with Bashir, Part 1

 (Click to E-mail this Tomgram, or post to Facebook, Digg, Reddit and many others)

As a 19-year-old Israeli soldier, Ari Folman took part in the 1982 invasion of Lebanon and was on duty in Beirut during the notorious massacres in the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Shatila. Just a week ago, Waltz with Bashir, the animated documentary film Folman directed in which he explores his own nightmarish, half-suppressed memories of that period, was given its first underground screening in Lebanon -- not far, in fact, from Hezbollah headquarters in southern Beirut -- though the film is officially banned in that country. It has also been screened in Palestinian Ramallah and is reportedly soon to be shown in the Arab Gulf states. It has already won six Israeli Academy Awards, best foreign film at the Golden Globes, and is now nominated for an Oscar as best foreign film.

At this moment, when the Israeli assault on Gaza has ended in catastrophic destruction and death, director Folman's remarkable voyage -- he calls it a "bad acid trip" -- into the oblivion of war trauma and the horrific recent history of the Middle East is as stunning, moving, and unnerving an experience as anything you'll see this year, or perhaps any year. A no less remarkable graphic memoir, Waltz with Bashir, was developed in tandem with the film. It will be in your bookstores in a couple of weeks, but can be ordered in advance by clicking here. Not surprisingly, the book and film have some of the impact that the first "graphic novel," Art Spiegelman's MAUS, had when it came out in 1986, and that assessment comes from the fellow -- me, to be exact -- who published MAUS back then.

The single best piece on Waltz with Bashir and its relevance to the recent invasion of Gaza was written by Gary Kamiya of Salon.com. He concludes: "Of course, Israel's moral culpability for the 1982 massacre [in Sabra and Shatila] is not the same as its moral responsibility for the civilians killed in the current war. But there are painful similarities. Sooner or later the patriotic war fervor will fade, and Israelis will realize that their leaders sent them to kill hundreds of innocent people for nothing. And perhaps in 2036, some haunted filmmaker will release 'Waltz With Hamas.'"

Given the power and timeliness of this thoughtful, dreamlike memoir from a living hell, it's a particular honor for TomDispatch to be releasing two long excerpts, exclusively, over the next two Saturdays. Thanks go to Metropolitan Books, the book's publisher, for allowing it to happen. I hope what follows stuns and intrigues you. Keep an eye out for part 2 next Saturday. Tom





WALTZ WITH BASHIR: A Lebanon War Story by Ari Folman and David Polonsky. Copyright © 2009 by Ari Folman / Bridgit Folman Films Gang. Published by arrangement with Metropolitan Books, an Imprint of Henry Holt and Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Embed code for the above excerpt:

Printer-Friendly Version

book

The World According to TomDispatch

For many of us, these are the key pieces of analysis that made sense of our post-9/11 world.
- Naomi Klein

The publication of this splendid collection of dispatches is cause for celebration.
- Andrew Bacevich

Click to read about this book, reviews and blurbs, or to buy.

book

Hope in the Dark

Untold Histories, Wild Possibilities

By Rebecca Solnit


"Seemingly lost in the woods of deceit and banality, bereft of hope, we are confronted by Rebecca Solnit and her astonishing flashlight. In a jewel of a book that is poetic in substance as well as style, she reveals where we were, where we are and the step-by-step advances that have been made in human rights, as we stubbornly stumble out of the darkness." --Studs Terkel

Nation Books

TomDispatch Video

Chalmers Johnson
Nick Turse
Howard Zinn
Mike Klare
Ann Jones
Tom Engelhardt
Rick Shenkman
Andrew Bacevich

Websites

After Downing Street
Alternet
Antiwar.com
Atlantic Free Press
Black Agenda Report
Buzzflash
Commondreams
Cursor.org
Electronic Iraq
Fabius Maximus
Foreign Policy in Focus
History News Network
Iraq Slogger
Juan Cole's Informed Comment
Lew Rockwell
Open Democracy
PEJ
The Smirking Chimp
Talking Points Memo
TomPaine
TPM Muckraker
Truthdig
Truthout
War in Context
Working for Change
ZNET

Blogs

The American Empire Project
Barbara's Blog
Democrats.com
Dahr Jamail's MidEast Dispatches
Dan Froomkin's White House Watch
Direland
The Dreyfuss Report
Econowhiner
Eric Alterman's Altercation
Firedoglake
Gristmill Blog
Inter Press Service
Lobelog
The Notion at the Nation
Scott Horton's No Comment
This Modern World
A Tiny Revolution
Tony Karon's Rootless Cosmopolitan
The Utne Reader
William Arkin's Early Warning

Foreign

AlArab Online
Agence France Presse
Asia Times
BBC
Foreign Press Review
The Guardian
Haaretz
The Independent
Middle East On-Line
LeMonde Diplomatique
Le Monde Diplomatique (English Language)
Outlook India
Watching America

Magazines

American Prospect
Bulletin of Atomic Scientists
Grist
Guernica
LA Weekly
The London Review of Books
Mother Jones
The Nation
The New York Review of Books
Salon.com

Media Criticism

Editor and Publisher
The E&P Pub
FAIR
Media Bloodhound
Media Matters
The News Dissector
Neiman Watchdog
PressThink
Romenesko

Resources

Arms Trade Resource Center
Defense Tech
Global Security.org
Jim Lobe's Interpress Archive
The National Security Archives
Natural Resources Defense Council
Noah Schachtman's Danger Room
Right Web
Secrecy News
USC Center on Public Diplomacy
Wikipedia

Comics

Doonesbury
Life During Wartime
Tom Tomorrow's This Modern World

Polling

Donkey Rising
Pollster.com
ProfessorPollkatz's Pool of Polls
Program on International Policy Attitudes
Real Clear Politics
Zogby

Iraq Casualty Figures

Antiwar.com Casualties Page
Antiwar.com Daily Casualty Update
Iraq Body Count
Iraq Coalition Casualties

Mainstream Media

Christian Science Monitor
Los Angeles Times
Newsweek
New York Times
Washington Post


Tom Engelhardt's articles from around the web


Why the US Military Loves Ron Paul
July 23, 2007, The Nation website

Order 17
September 24, 2007, The Nation website

We Count, They Don't
October 4, 2007, The Nation website

Medal Inflation
October 9, 2007, The Nation website

Tom's Review of Books
December 11, 2007, TomDispatch..